Many reviewers treated director Josh Safdie’s Oscar-nominated film Marty Supreme as only a sports drama or a tale of the crazed pursuit of success. On its surface an account of the 1950s-era, Jewish, working-class would-be ping pong champion Marty Mauser, it is actually a devastating critique of the ways that people in a capitalist society enslave one another – whether as employers, family members, or lovers — in pursuit of wealth or stability. Reviewers focusing on Marty’s supposedly bad behavior miss the film’s subversive core – a Jewish-inflected, anti-capitalist account of a working-class man’s entirely justified struggle to express his talents and to resist appropriation of the surplus value he produces.
The film opens with Marty having sex with his girlfriend, and then zeros in on countless microscopic sperm seeking an egg — a clichéd but functional representation of crazed competition. At the time of this coupling, Marty is in the back room of his place of employment, a Lower East Side shoe store owned by his uncle. The first example of Marty’s bad behavior, aside from having sex at work, is his breaking into his uncle’s safe to take $500 that he needs for a ping-pong competition in England. But crucially, Marty’s act isn’t theft – it is restitution. The cash that he grabs is money that he had earned through his labor at the shoe store, but that his uncle had unjustly withheld from him. (His uncle explains that Marty must continue working for him because he, the uncle, cannot support Marty’s mother indefinitely – family bonds are never untouched by economic need or desire in this film.) Nevertheless, Marty’s attempt to reverse his uncle’s wage-theft and pursue his own desires marks him as a criminal.
The pattern is thus set of Marty’s supposedly outrageous behavior that, on closer look, is only outrageous if one thinks that class hierarchies are natural and must always be respected. Marty goes to England for his match, where he discovers that the workers who produce value – in this case, the ping pong players – are forced to room in a dark hovel, stacked up in bunk beds, while the owning class that lives off their labor swanks it up in a first-class hotel. Marty is uncouth enough to protest this exploitative arrangement. He loudly insists on his right to stay at the same hotel as the bosses – that is, to have an equal share in the wealth he produces. Naturally, the bosses cast Marty as the problem. They mock and demean him for his ingratitude, that is for his refusal to accept existing social arrangements.
Marty loses the British ping pong competition to Koto Endo, a deaf and enormously dignified player who is a survivor of the U.S bombings of Tokyo. With no money to get home, Marty agrees to join his friend and sometime rival, Bela Kletzki, as the opening act in the Harlem Globetrotter’s global tour. This touring show requires these athletes, along with Marty and Kletzki, to perform humiliating stunts and parodies of their own talent.
Like Endo, Kletzki has been marked by the recent global war. An Auschwitz survivor and former ping-pong champion, Kletzki embodies the spirit of cooperation. In the film’s sole flashback, he recalls how once, while performing his forced labor of disabling bombs in the woods, he saw a honeybee. He follows it to its hive, where he takes off his shirt and smears the hive’s honey over his chest and arms. After returning to his barracks, he removes his shirt so that his famished bunkmates could lick the honey off his body, an action that is maternal and sacrificial. Kletzki uses his body and his skill to feed others rather than to prey upon them. He even plays ping-pong cooperatively, respecting the talents of opponents and accepting losses with grace.
But while Kletzki embodies a perhaps Christian ethos of acceptance and self-sacrifice, Marty craves the Old Testament value of justice. On the tour, Marty’s “bad” behavior continues. For example, when the Harlem Globetrotters tour takes him to Egypt, he does the unthinkable – while others pose in front of the Great Pyramid, Marty surreptitiously saws off a piece of this priceless monument. But we soon learn why. When Marty returns to New York City, he gives the pyramid piece to his mother. She deserves this memento, Marty explains, since, after all, “We built it.” Here is the theme of the film: those who labor deserve a fair division of the rewards, even in a world where doing so means upsetting social norms.
Back home, Marty has more chaos to untangle. His uncle sends a police officer to arrest him for stealing the wages he was owed. Marty receives an enormous bill for his time at the swanky British hotel, along with the message that he won’t be allowed to play in the upcoming world ping pong championship unless he pays it. His girlfriend Rachel is pregnant with his baby, she claims, and also, we learn, stuck in a marriage she doesn’t want. There’s a subplot concerning a dog named, of course, Moses, who, like Marty, is a wild, powerful creature who others continually try to contain as private property.
As a result of these and other complications, Marty once again finds himself without the money he needs to get to the next international ping pong tournament, this one in Japan. He is forced to beg a vicious, highly successful businessman, Milton Rockwell, for financial assistance. Marty has been sleeping with Rockwell’s wife Kay, but the business man is unaware of this. He simply observes that Marty is in a financially desperate situation and can therefore be easily exploited.
Rockwell agrees to pay Marty’s way to Japan. In return, he steals Marty’s idea of how to use his own, company-sponsored ping-pong competition to sell his product in Japan. He also forces Marty to stage a loss to Endo there. As a final sadistic touch, Rockwell makes Marty pull down his pants, bend over, and allow Rockwell to beat his naked behind with a ping pong paddle, in full view of his wealthy, chortling friends. Rockwell can do all of this because, as he tells Marty, “you have no power here.” The gold rims of his glasses glinting, Rockwell helpfully tells Marty that monsters like himself have been around since the 1600s (that is, since the birth of capitalism).
The two major female characters in the film provide possible counterweights to the brute capitalist exploitation that Rockwell exemplifies. One is Rockwell’s wife Kay, a former actress and occasional lover of Marty’s. She has been married to Rockwell for twenty-five miserable years. Rockwell gives her a jeweled necklace for each year of marriage, which she bears like so many chains. Having ruined her life in exchange for wealth and stability, Kay has no loyalty to her new class. Instead, she is happy to participate in the redistribution of wealth. After Kay learns that Marty had stolen a piece of her jewelry – costume, it turns out — in the hopes of pawning it for the cash he needed to travel to Japan, Kay tells him, “I don’t care. I would have stolen from me too.”
Just before Marty begs Rockwell for money to travel to Japan, Kay had met Marty in Central Park. There she gave him an authentic, diamond-studded necklace she had received from Rockwell. Marty is stunned by her generosity, and ecstatic because it will easily pay his way to Japan. The two fall to the ground embracing, and Marty is performing oral sex on Kay when the police arrive. Alas, freely sharing either wealth or sexual pleasure is not allowed. The police threaten Kay, confiscate Marty’s necklace, and walk off with their loot. It is this final theft, this time by police, that leaves Marty no other choice but to abase himself before Rockwell. (As a side note, the police in this film appear only to enrich themselves, or to enforce illegal scams by the better-off against their weaker victims.)
The film’s other female lead is Rachel, Marty’s childhood friend and (other) current lover. Again, the movie opens with her and Marty having sex. Eight months later, when Marty returns from his Harlem Globetrotters tour, he finds her at work in a pet store, pregnant and surrounded by cages. In yet another example of Marty’s seemingly awful behavior, he immediately tells her that he is not the child’s father. Rachel convinces him that the child is his, and furthermore, that her husband Ira beats her. Both claims turn out to be false.
Rachel, it turns out, is in a stifling working-class marriage, just as Kay languishes in a bad elite marriage. While Kay suffers quietly and rebels surreptitiously, Rachel takes action. Deciding that she prefers Marty to Ira, she does what she needs to do to get him. In a parallel to Marty’s own willingness to say and do anything, she lies and maneuvers, but also shows great cunning and courage in escaping a life that she doesn’t want. But neither Rachel nor Marty are motivated by money. Instead, they want joy, action, and self-expression. As Marty snaps at the wealthy parents of one of his friends, “I gave him purpose; you only gave him money.”
In the film’s conclusion, Rockwell pays Marty’s way to Tokyo tournament. Although Marty remains barred from the world ping pong championship because of his bad behavior in England, he triumphs in an unofficial, impromptu match with Endo that he barely wins. He returns to the U.S. to find that Rachel has given birth a month “early” (that is, eight rather than nine months after her sexual encounter with Marty). Overwhelmed by the intensity of the previous eight months, Marty holds the baby and weeps, overlooking the baby’s scowling face and its undeniable resemblance to Rachel’s (now presumably former) husband, Ira. The soundtrack wells up with Tears for Fears’ classic “Everybody Wants to Rule the World,” with its opening lines of “welcome to your life, there’s no turning back.” In a world structured by hierarchies of class and gender, as well as race and ethnicity, one person’s security is another person’s pain, and that remains the final lesson of Marty Supreme.
