pittsburgh review of books logo

On Making Friends with Agatha Christie

“But that is the thing with reading: it is a capacious and surprising activity. I came to Agatha for distraction and comfort. I got that, but I also got so much more.”

When I decided to read all of Agatha Christie in publication date order, I was tired and miserable and looking for the comfort of familiarity. I’ve loved the books since childhood, and I’m always using the audio versions to keep me company as I reluctantly cook and clean (the best treat is to read one in the bath). The enjoyable puzzles and gentle humour distracted me from my woes and then, when all was revealed at the end, I experienced that blissful feeling of “order restored,” which felt   impossible to achieve in my life.

 Christie wrote 66 crime novels. Fantastic, I thought. I’ve always loved a reading project. Once I’m done, I’ll have “order restored” 66 times in a row—the one area of my life where I know what’s happening and what I’m doing.

Christie wrote The Mysterious Affair at Styles in 1916 and Postern of Fate in 1972, essentially covering a large chunk of the 20th century. The first books are full of servants, but then butlers, housekeepers, and parlour maids disappear in the later books. When do women start divorcing unpleasant husbands rather than murdering them? I’d collect mentions of disused train stations, cars, and habits that are no longer part of our world. There are lots of real and fictional books, I could write all those down too. And I could also make a list of murder methods and motives, along with a chart that tracked social change. That was the plan.

But from the very moment I started, I wanted to know more about the writer herself. . I’d read plenty of biographies over the years about Agatha Christie, one of the most successful writers of the 20th century (only outsold by Shakespeare and the Bible), whose life was marred by the eleven days in 1926 when she’d gone missing to be discovered safe in a hotel in Harrogate. No, this immersion into her words made me curious about the woman behind the story, and my chronological approach was showing me how she put herself and her experiences into the novels from the very first pages. Thus, her autobiography became my constant companion.

At first, I thought there was rather too much about her childhood. If I was editing this,  I’d be crossing out lots of these details. But I kept reading and noting how she composed her life on to the page, from the floral wallpaper in her nursery to the monkey puzzle tree in the garden, to giving her grandmother’s home-made cherry brandy to Miss Marple. As time went on, I wasn’t just reading between the lines but above, beneath, around and beyond them.  I didn’t want to read her like a critic or a biographer. Instead, I’d read her like I was a friend—.Agatha would become Christie.

She was famously shy. But when I read The Grand Tour, a collection of letters she wrote home to her mother from the around-the-world trip she took in 1922, I saw how lively and gregarious she was before she was so bruised by the exposure of Harrogate. Up to meeting strangers, at some point I began to feel like she was up to meeting me. When I got the flu and could hardly get out of bed for a month, I started dreaming about her. At first, she’d say the things I’d read about, but then she went further, giving me good, robust advice. And she was so kind. I assumed it was all part of my illness, a bookworm specific symptom, but it didn’t stop as I got better.

 I was lonely, which is a vulnerable way to be.  I moved with my husband and son from London to Cornwall in 2017, hoping it would solve all our problems. I thought we might all be happier and healthier in the land of my birth, by the sea, with my parents down the road. I hoped my husband would cheer up, that more access to nature might help him be less angry about Brexit and other terrible decisions taken by the global electorate. Not that I disagreed with him about how upsetting everything was. I just didn’t want our lives to be completely dominated by his reaction to events over which we had no control.  I loved my son and parents, but as I gradually and painfully accepted that this marriage was coming to an end, what I really longed for was a friend—someone who would come and sit and talk to me in my kitchen. I’d go off to literary events and meet brilliant women and say, why can’t you come and live next door and then pop around and chat while I tidy up? I know lots of people would find it more difficult to be on stage in front of strangers than at home doing their chores, but not me. All my worries dissolve when I’m on stage and liberated from the pebbly crap of obligation and responsibility I can be present to what really matters. Back in my own kitchen, I find the domestic load so difficult as to be almost unbearable and continually feel overwhelmed, confused and inadequate.

I needed someone to come around to take my mind off my shortcomings and Agatha stepped up. She was nourishing and stimulating at the same time, which is my favourite thing and hard to come by. We had more in common than I thought, including a childhood so happy that we felt unprepared for the slings and arrows of grown-up life. She liked writing about her childhood because she was safest there in the company of her loving parents. She took solace in loitering in those years before anything went wrong, when her world was an Eden and her only problem was the occasional bilious attack from eating too many green apples. I was learning so much from her. She knew about grief and heartbreak and how to survive. She had a great sense of perspective and helped me escape the noise of the now—to tune into universal truths. And she helped me buckle down to my responsibilities and kept me company while I did it.

I knew I might be projecting, seeing what I wanted to see. But don’t we do that in all relationships? Isn’t part of the agony of separation that we must confront the gap between what we hallucinated and what actually was? If we rigorously interrogate ourselves, don’t we often find that, really, we knew all along? The evidence was there, but we willfully blinded ourselves to anything that got in the way of our vision. That this person would give us our happy ending, the one that books, TV, and films have trained us to expect but  is so elusive in real life.

 As a reader, I’ve always liked that books are so reliable compared to human beings: You can get one off the shelf whenever you like. They don’t have their own agenda. They don’t die.  They might have changed since you last met, but that is another story and more about you than them. With Agatha I felt safe. I didn’t have to worry that I might offend her, that she might judge me or ditch me for some imagined slight. She knew what it felt like to be unappreciated and betrayed. She wasn’t going to do that to me.

When I started my reading project, all I was after was something enjoyable and soothing to do, for a way to feel better in a way that didn’t eventually leave me feeling worse after. But that is the thing with reading: it is a capacious and surprising activity. I came to Agatha for distraction and comfort.  I got that, but I also got so much more. I have always said to aspiring writers: “Don’t let practicalities limit your choice of writing mentor.” If you feel like someone is speaking to you, then maybe they are. I’ve been doing that as a writer for years—trying to be hospitable, hoping readers will take up the invitation to bring their own selves into the pages if I leave space. Books are magical. They are some thousands of words all in the right order, but once a reader arrives to activate its multidimensionality, it can be so much more.

Is that what I did? Open the covers to find not just a world but a friend? I don’t know if I’ll ever do it again. I doubt it could work with anyone who is alive as it would feel like taking liberties, and I tend to shy away from meeting living writers I admire. And I’m also wary of extending friendships to deceased writers in general. It has been intense and Agatha is very sensible and well-balanced, compared to many of the writers on my shelves. A good egg. A decent human being. Not everyone might be such a positive influence. Anyway, I’ve a feeling I’m not done with Agatha, nor is she with me. As in a flesh and blood relationship, she reveals herself in layers. She might have more to tell me when she’s ready. Perhaps it is time to start reading those 66 books again. I might even remember to make some lists this time.

About the Author

Cathy Rentzenbrink first fell in love with the books of Agatha Christie at the age of nine, when her grandmother introduced her to them and paid her ten cents for every Christie mystery she finished. An avid reader ever since, Cathy went on to work as a bookseller at Waterstones and as the Books Editor at The Bookseller before becoming the Sunday Times top ten bestselling author of The Last Act of Love, and many other titles. When she faced the end of her marriage around her fiftieth birthday, Cathy sought relief in Christie’s books once more and found they gave her the emotional glue she needed. She remains a staunch fan of any mug with an Agatha Christie quote on it.

Get the latest delivered to your inbox!

More Like This

Back to top ↑