pittsburgh review of books logo

Our Metropolis

“This heartless contrast of rich and poor had seldom been risked before in movies.”

It was just before the opening of Greed (December 1924) that Fritz Lang beheld New York City. He was more thrilled by the skyscrapers than most American films had bothered to be. He was the son of an architect so maybe he was raised to see not just the vertical beauty of it all but how the buildings manifested a new social contract that was required after the Great War. He wanted to make a movie about that urban dynamic and the struggle for human liberty that lay beneath it. Lang was another Viennese, born there in 1890. His mother had been Jewish before becoming a Catholic. As a young man he had thought of being a painter and he was an admirer of Gustav Klimt and Egon Schiele. But he joined up with the Austro-Hungarian army in the war and he was wounded several times. That included the loss of an eye, which only seemed to concentrate his passion for com-position. It was while recuperating from his wounds (and learning how to use a monocle) that he tried writing a few film scripts. These were shown to producers and Lang was on his way. Immediately, he had an awesome ambition for projects that were part of the German feeling that cinema was already a vital art. In Germany, as was not yet true in America, films were to be aimed at the educated classes as much as at the rabble.

Der müde Tod (Destiny) (1921), was a costumed fable with three stories in which the figure of Death comes to test young lovers. DieSpinnen was a two-part adventure story about an underworld gang. America seemed to trust movie imagery, but in Germany an anxiety, or paranoia, warned audiences to be suspicious. So Lang felt the possibility of criminal structures that mimicked the forces of law and order. Most impressive of all these early films is Dr. Mabuse, der Spieler (1922), another two-part picture about a madman, Dr. Mabuse, who wants to take over the world as a way of getting to destroy it. There was a sinister cast to this project, driven by some psychology as well as a vision of the city as a warren, that would never have been dared in American film. But Lang was unimpressed by the storylines that satisfied America, like justice, true love, and doing the right thing. Then in 1923, he opened nothing less than Die Nibelungen, another two-parter, with Siegfried and Kriemhild’s Revenge. This is Richard Wagner on the silent screen, at immense expense and a humorless but strenuous magic, with cardboard dragons and tumultuous fight scenes. Die Nibelungen was well received in Europe, often in concert halls, where it was a cultural event such as Griffith and Stroheim would have envied. In a few years, Lang had established himself as a visionary, and it was with that reputation that when he proposed to make a film about Manhattan’s meaning (though shot on Berlin sets), UFA (the major German studio) signed on and started writing checks. Metropolis would astonish the world, though it brought UFA close to bankruptcy. It was said to be the most expensive film yet made in Europe—the equivalent of $1 million was boasted about. But emphatically Fritz Lang was in the business of being important.

I can’t deride that boyish urge, but the history of movie importance (especially when announced in advance) is not good.

Die Nibelungen has a sense of Aryan mythology that might be comic if we didn’t know the history of the next twenty years. Some audiences were enthralled by it. The party worker Adolf Hitler, before he was sent to prison, reckoned he saw it twenty times. What does it say about anyone seeing a picture that often? It’s like being with a lover, or with someone who wants to be in love.

Lang never depicted Manhattan in Metropolis. The future city has only two places for us to see: the workers’ underground domain, and the penthouse where the owners live. The workers’ city is a prison where the inmates wear drab uniforms and shuffle back and forth like automatons. “Men, men, men—all in the same uniform, from throat to ankle in dark blue linen, bare feet in the same hard shoes, hair tightly pressed down by the same black caps. And they all had the same face. And they all seemed one thousand years old.  They

planted their feet forward but they did not walk. The open gates of the New Tower of Babel, the machine centre of Metropolis, threw up the masses as it gulped them down.” Very soon we will discover one of their tasks: to move the hands of a giant clock as lights indicate. They are keeping and making time itself in the slave state.

High above them live the owners. “The ‘Club of the Sons’ was, perhaps, one of the most beautiful of Metropolis, and that was not so very remarkable. For fathers, for whom every revolution of a machine-wheel spelled gold, had presented this house to their sons. It was more a district than a house. It embraced theatres, picture-palaces, lecture-rooms and a library race tracks and stadium and the famous ‘Eternal Gardens.’”

This heartless contrast of rich and poor had seldom been risked before in movies. We see the sons, not in nature but in an artificial light without warmth, bare-chested, running for the fun and health of it. And with expressions of exultation on their faces. Above and below, there are only men. This is an early sign of immaculate fas-cist strength or purity. We are not in Kansas anymore, but in an abstraction of social order with an implacable distance between the many and the few.

Outside we have the special effects apparition of a city, plainly inspired by Manhattan, where “the car speeds across a bridge thrown between towering factory and office blocks, while slow-moving trucks carry workers along an elevated road beneath. The canyon-like walls of the city blocks rise far above any street level.Cars and trains speed along overhead tracks, airplanes circle like moths . . .”

This is Lang’s vision and UFA’s fabrication, the futurism of décor—by Otto Hunte, Erich Kettelhut, and Karl Vollbrecht. It is an unprecedented futurism for 1927, and Metropolis is supposedly set (spoiler alert) in the year 2026, but this is a scheme of design ideologically opposed to natural light or fresh air. The man-made has eliminated nature. We know this scheme now from so many films—King Kong, Blade Runner, The Truman Show, Megalopolis, and even The Brutalist (which seems as if it might have had the same architect as did Metropolis). (Did I really say The Truman Show? That film seems full of sunshine and “Seahaven Island,” but it’s all an enormous ideological set.)

The production design is not just science fiction to impress an audience. It is a matter of belief, a worship of all the engines turn-ing over—and it is in sync with an exultation with cinema itself as a machine. Lang pictures often talk about our free will, but they vibrate with the repetition of the engine.

The workers of Metropolis are not just depressed and anony-mous. They want to protest their conditions and the contrast in life. There is even a valiant young woman, Maria, among the workers who pleads for more understanding and is perceived as a trouble-maker by Joh Fredersen “the Master of Metropolis,” an austere man, the emblem of unkind authority. He wants to undermine Maria and to do so he has made a robot duplicate, who so resembles her that the masses will think Maria is the lascivious dancing girl the robot acts out to divert attention.

Masters of Metropolis often lack the skills for making robots, so Fredersen turns to the most dynamic male figure in the movie, Rotwang: “We now see Rotwang himself, wearing a dark smock, poring over a diagram on his work table. He is old and grey-haired, with beetling brows, and his right hand is artificial, made of a dark, glistening material.”

That note is from Thea von Harbou’s script, and surely it had in mind the actor who was meant to play Rotwang. That was Rudolf Klein-Rogge. Von Harbou could picture him because she had been married to him before she left him for Lang. There was this curi-ous triangle in which Klein-Rogge was Lang’s most valuable actor: He had played in Der müde Tod; he had been Dr. Mabuse and King Etzel in Siegfried. He was only five years older than Lang and he would be loyal to the man who had taken his wife. They worked together, though it was common knowledge in the business that after marrying von Harbou, Lang entered into many other affairs, notably with actresses.

This is not just gossip. There was a kind of incest at work, and an emotional authoritarianism all the stranger in that Klein-Rogge really expressed Lang’s fascination with evil masterminds. To the quick outward eye, his pictures end in moral resolution, often imposed and unconvincing, but the heartbeat of the films—their obsessive intensity—depends on the evil. (And yes, Rotwang now reminds us of Dr. Strangelove.)

Thea von Harbou had been Lang’s screenwriter since Der müde Tod. He leaned heavily on her fevered plotting. That marriage was not totally romantic. There had been an earlier marriage for Fritz Lang, and that wife (Lisa Rosenthal) had been found dead in her bath, shot by Lang’s own revolver. It remains unclear exactly how that happened. But some thought it had been suicide or even murder. Lang was not the most appealing of men.

Von Harbou’s writing was rapid and portentous but as if written for children; she had that odd clash of impulses that is never too far away from the existential melodrama of movieness. The trashy impact that wants to be profound. When the film opened, many reviewers commented on its naive flourishes; that is one reason why the film was a failure. But Metropolis has lasted, as if it had its fingers on a pulse we might not care to admit—or treat. And that is still a confrontation in modern society and in the minds of leadersintent on saving us, even if it means wiping us out along the way. From the outset, Metropolis felt like a frantic charade in which we could not deny seeing figures from our nightmares. It’s legitimate to spell out the tedious sentimentality in Griffith’s people. But he cared for them. Lang is a new visionary: He doesn’t give a damn for them, compared with his raptures over form.

Metropolis would seem sillier but for the relentlessness in how Lang frames shots and builds sequences. The film was over three hundred days in the shooting and the building of sets. As soon as one starts to smile at childish conceits, along comes a passage of headlong cinema. Much of this is grounded in one actress, Brigitte Helm, playing both the sweet Maria and the unprincipled robot, who manages to be a very erotic dancer. There had been films before where one actor played two roles: In 1920, John Barrymore was both Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde in a film, and that novella was the rich soil in which flexibility bloomed. Robert Louis Stevenson had his doctor become a brute by taking an elixir—but suppose the shift can come just from thinking. Few films had been so fixed on mistaken identity and the insinuation—for any young woman in the audience—that you might be a saint and a whore.

After all, actors and actresses get to play a wide range of char-acters, but as careers build, so we digest the differences involved. We know that Bogart was a nasty rat for much of the 1930s, until he turned into Sam Spade in The Maltese Falcon and Rick in Casablanca. Or think of Meryl Streep as Sophie or the editor in The Devil Wears Prada. Think of any actor—even those most thoroughly typecast—and you are dealing in your imagination with their variety. In short, people are not fixed or reliable. That’s not only actors; it’s us in the dark dreaming of being other people. That instability of identity is a primary lesson in movie and it has to do with why Lang couldn’t care.

Metropolis winds itself down finally. The wicked Maria is burned at the stake. Fredersen sees the light and assures everyone that he will improve conditions for the workers. We never see that or hearthat they have won membership at the Eternal Gardens. There is a vapid motto for one and all, not far from the way American movies liked to end on a bright note. “There can be no understanding between the hands and the brain unless the heart acts as mediator.” Again, we do not see this reform in action, just as the film does not explain why or how the gulf opened between the workers and the bosses. Spending $1 million in deutsche marks doesn’t get you everything.

The German audience was amazed by Metropolis and even proud at its scope. But not too many enjoyed it; it was like a lecture done as a futuristic pageant; its characters were not alluring or sentimental. As a result, the UFA studio was so overextended that it was taken over by Alfred Hugenberg, a right-wing media magnate. That is more than show-business history; it was a step in Germany’s move to the right. This was after UFA had been the home where Ernst Lubitsch and F. W. Murnau (as well as Lang) had been part of a dynamic era in German movie production so notable that both Lubitsch and Murnau were invited away to Hollywood. Hugenberg became an influential figure in the nation and one of the establishment leaders who approved and enabled the rise of Adolf Hitler so that UFA had no choice but to become an instrument in Nazi film promotion. So much for the healing homily that concludes Metropolis.

But Lang remained and did his best work in the next few years. He made the exhilarating Spione, in which Klein-Rogge played another mastermind, and Frau im Mond (Woman in the Moon), a science-fiction doldrum with a moonscape that looks like Death Valley done as a cheap set. The best thing about this picture (only 168 minutes) is that the Nazis confiscated it because they feared its rocket ship was a giveaway on their flying bombs.

At that point, 1931, with sound inescapable, Lang heeded von Harbou’s urging to make a film about a child killer. There had beensuch cases in Germany at the time, frightening so many parents. Lang was nervous about getting that close to real anxiety; he thought the subject might be too much for audiences. But von Harbou insisted. She wrote a very good script in which the killer makes a desperate explanation of his terrible impulses—and Lang remembered a rare actor he had seen onstage, Peter Lorre.

The result was M, an authentic tragedy such as Lang seldom delivered, and a film that demonstrated how sound was about to accelerate the intelligence possible in cinema. This is still a film for grown-ups, and the director’s most frightening portrait of urban loneliness and its pressure on crime and murder. Lorre’s killer is an unprecedented delving into madness, and a performance that would make his career while trapping him as a bogeyman. Von Harbou’s instinct had been correct. Audiences watched in horror but also something like sympathy. The killer suddenly had an open future on the screen. In America, that energy was evident in the snarling strut of Jimmy Cagney and Edward G. Robinson. The scene where Lorre’s character sees the white “M” that has been chalked on his black coat by an underworld figure—and sees it in a mirror on the street—was a breathtaking emblem of cinema as a window on the inner mind. It is a moment when, despite homilies and the indus-trial urge to make us feel good, a kind of horror arises that makes Dracula seem quaint.

As Germany lurched toward its catastrophe, Lang, von Harbou, and Klein-Rogge joined forces for the last time. The Testament of Dr. Mabuse was a reprise of the old mastermind in a thriller so crammed with activity and rigorous, penetrating camera angles that the film felt claustrophobic. Later on, Lang would say that Mabuse gave voice to Nazi theories. I think that was hindsight convenience. It’s more telling that Lang seems entranced by the mad doctor’s vision and skill as a manipulative force. All over the world, directors of crime thrillers would copy The Testament, not least in its eager manipulation of the crowd.Timing now was of the essence. Hitler became chancellor just before The Testament of Dr. Mabuse was about to open. The word came down from the new minister of the interior, Joseph Goeb-bels, that The Testament would have to be banned—it might upset or inflame the people with its lust for crime. But Goebbels offered a reward. There was a meeting with Lang in which Goebbels told the story of how, back in 1927, he and Hitler had seen Metropo-lis several times and Hitler had said that Lang was the man who should make the great movies for the Reich. That is a scene for a Lang film. Two men at a desk; the crosscut close-ups; two battling smiles; and the threat of damnation. With this extra: that, like other fascists, Hitler felt an innate excitement at how movie worked. Just because he was a monster doesn’t mean he couldn’t grasp a film’s feeling when he saw it. Maybe that helped; maybe the dream spurs authoritarianism.

Before long, Lang would tell his story—in France and then in America—that on the spot with Goebbels he knew his game was up. So overnight, with the banks closed, he cashed in Thea’s jewels and fled for freedom . . . and Hollywood. That’s what a hero in an adven-ture movie might do. But close research (by Patrick McGilligan) would uncover a subtler truth: how Lang waited several months, as if of two minds or in hesitation, taking trips outside Germany, gath-ering his funds, where he paused on his staircase for fear of falling. He would be in Hollywood by 1934, a regular filmmaker, but never again a dominant success or comfortable in studio competition. He made several good films—Fury; You Only Live Once; Man Hunt; Ministry of Fear; The Woman in the Window; The Big Heat—gloomy, fatalistic, without a shred of hope, regarding his own characters as rats in an experiment.

Thea von Harbou stayed in Germany and rode along on the Nazi staircase. So it goes, but Lang was never quite the same without her. So many refugees change country and seem to do well, but they risk losing a part of themselves.

Meanwhile

The practice of cinema in the 1930s led to a culture of exiles or escapees, people who had to do their vital work somewhere else. We have learned about those jitters now, of living in so many locations that we feel unattached, but we have to recall how that transitioning was nearly unknown a generation or two earlier. Take Max Ophüls, born in Saarbrücken in 1902; died in Hamburg in 1957. That seems a short, local life. But Ophüls was forever in motion. No wonder he is the maestro of films that understand the passions of a moving camera and the passage of time. So he made his first masterpiece about lost love, Liebelei, in Germany in 1933. But then (he was a Jew) he had to move to France and to Italy (La Signora di Tutti). He made a film in Holland—in Dutch. Then France again in the late thirties (From Mayerling to Sarajevo, another sad journey), and then at last to America and vexed years where the business could neither pronounce nor spell his name. Still, he made three trembling films there—Letter from an Unknown Woman, with Louis Jourdan as a dissolute concert pianist who barely recalls seducing Joan Fontaine, and then remembers too late; Caught, a dark romance with James Mason as a humble doctor, Robert Ryan playing a version of Howard Hughes, and Barbara Bel Geddes as the woman caught between them—there is a shot in that film, on a dance floor, with Mason and Bel Geddes, where we feel minds changing as they move with the music; and then The Reckless Moment, a melodrama with Mason and Joan Bennett, about second chances coming too late.

But Hollywood didn’t appreciate Max and he went back to France and made three of the loveliest films ever done anywhere—Le Plaisir (from de Maupassant stories); Madame de . . . (that was Andrew Sarris’s favorite film); and Lola Montès, a chronicle of the notorious scarlet woman all done within a circus show where she travesties her life for the raw public, with Peter Ustinov as the ringmaster impre-sario who loves her but has to crack a whip to order the tableauxof her career. And Martine Carol as Lola, aging before our eyes and beyond saving.

Like Lola, Max was dying as he made her film. It was a period piece in CinemaScope, but utterly modern. He had no greater fan than François Truffaut (himself longing to direct), and when Ophüls died, Truffaut wrote this:

He confided to me that he had systematically put into the plot of Lola Montès everything that had troubled or disturbed him in the newspapers in the preceding three months: Hollywood divorces, Judy Garland’s suicide attempt, Rita Hayworth’s adven-ture, American three-ring circuses, the advent of CinemaScope and Cinerama, the overemphasis on publicity, the exaggerations of modern life.

In Ophüls, we feel the last waves of Romanticism washing up on a frantic shore of media coverage.

Max and Fritz could not be more different in sentiment and timidity, but they were brothers on the run.

Excerpt from the book A Sudden Flicker of Light: A Revisionist History of Movies by David Thomson copyright © 2026 Simon & Schuster. Reproduced by permission.

About the Author

David Thomson is the author of more than twenty books, including biographies of David O. Selznick and Orson Welles, and The New Biographical Dictionary of Film. His writing and his books have been featured in The New York Times, The Guardian, the Los Angeles Times, The Atlantic, Esquire, Slate, and many more. He lives in San Francisco.

Get the latest delivered to your inbox!

More Like This

Back to top ↑