“I welcome you to this practice,
a practice of tuning into your body.
Tapping into and steadying every muscle.
Follow along as we turn our nervous system into a calm one. When you’re ready, let’s begin.” – Ela Plunar
On April 7, 2026 Donald Trump called for a genocide of the Iranian people: “A whole civilization will die tonight, never to be brought back again.” Apparently it is now officially sanctioned to advocate for ethnic extermination without relying on the pretenses or denial of past genocides. Civilization is no longer understood to be a dog whistle for race but an overt signifier for it. Official communications contrast “white civilization” against “other civilization,” thus accepting the ontological status of both and marking “other civilization” for death for no reason other than its supposed facticity.
This call for genocide has accompanied a criminal campaign of violence in Iran and a genocide in Palestine and Lebanon. The ethnic cleansing of Palestine and imperialism in the Levant and Persian Gulf has been a long process, the reduction of which to isolated events obscures the connections between the rapacious policies of different extractivist colonizers and authoritarian leaders. However, the recent escalation of violence does carry with it truly novel horrors. One of these is the open endorsement of extreme criminal violence (like Trump’s statement), signaling its bleak ubiquity in the neoliberal quotidian. This normalization is a direct result of the incorporation of extreme violence into image-based media platforms. Media platforms uplift these images for the express purpose of normalizing violence. In Gore Capitalism (2018) Sayak Valencia argues that:
Our ever-increasing consumption of decorative violence is evidence that the demands of the biomarket have made us believe it is desirable for the contemporary world to reproduce the scenography of war… These practices… expand the scope of violence considered permissible [and] also naturalize the indiscriminate use of violence through the participation-consumption of it by everyday citizens.
Here, Valencia is discussing the biomarket, a commodification of violence specific to criminal drug and human trafficking organizations. However, her words are just as accurate when applied to violence in the middle east. The outright criminality of the US government has evinced their adoption of a bloodlust shared by cartels and criminals, perhaps even been inspired by them.
This is traumatizing violence even when it is distributed via mass media for its trivialization, even when it is being distributed by media in reporting. Such violence necessitates a response. Naming the consumption of these images as violence in no way diminishes the acute violence experienced by the persecuted populations in question. Failing to name it violence would be a nihilistic and ignorant way of continuing to live in the heart of the neoliberal empire.
“Take your time to move into a comfortable seat.
A comfortable position, whatever your body needs, lay down, sit up straight, however you like, as long as your chest, and mind, is open. Gently close down the eyes, feel the space around you.”
The second reading is accompanied by the unique sound of sustained rin gongs, or singing bowls. They project from the either side of the vacated chancel, activated by two performers (myself and another member of my ensemble) sitting far apart and facing each other. In place of an altar there is a “Messiaen Quartet” – an ensemble consisting of clarinet, violin, cello, and piano. The six of us are performing under the auspices of the Antigone Music Collective, at a concert which I was responsible for curating as the artistic director.
The singing bowls are far enough apart that they are obscured for some in the audience, sitting as they are in a loose arrangement of reclaimed church pews, couches, and garden chairs where they become part of the immersive, acousmatic environment created by Katia Geha’s recorded guided meditation. In full view is a screen that once bore a projected image of a trigger warning on a piece of paper, which has since been lit on fire and burnt to ash before abruptly switching to black.
After almost an hour of acoustic instrumental music, the injunction made by this environment is striking. So far, only movements from Olivier Messaien’s Quartet for the End of Time, Bahar Royaee’s Tombstone, Mark Andre’s E2, and Reena Esmail’s Darshan have been heard. A certain austerity is set up by these sacred, quiet, and delicate works that is damaged by their juxtaposition against a pre-recorded human voice.
Katia Geha’s april 7 meditation ruptures the concert space. Tonight’s spatialized performances have traversed the chapel from front to sides to back before landing in its current place. Katia’s disembodied voice is projected from two speakers on either side of the stage. This and the spatialized, simultaneously played singing bowls produce an effect of being between the ears and inside the head. The audience is momentarily immersed in a homogenizing concert space which renders the forthcoming act of witnessing even more social and impactful while complicating the traditional audience/performer binary.
“Notice those tense points like your jaw, or shoulders, or stomach. Notice what’s on your mind and let it pass through you. Perhaps scanning from one side of the room to the other, nice and slowly, but just orienting yourself with the physical surroundings.
One deep breath in, Hold release.”
The medium of recorded sound bears resemblance to the spectacularized violence described above. Slowly, in a discordant counterpoint with the voice recordings and the singing bowls, we hear commotion and yelling, another ubiquitous part of the media landscape. Geha affirms this connection to violent media in her program note:
Meditation is part of my every day life, and on April 7, I decided to meditate as per usual. However, the problem I had encountered that day in my practice had been particularly bad compared to other days. That morning, I had watched a video on Instagram of a targeted attack against two Palestinian journalists in Gaza. The video displayed the two journalists, their media camp in flames, their corpses burning alive. During my meditation, I could not get this image out of my head.
This video is precisely what the audience is forewarned about by the yelling and commotion; it is what they will see when they are asked by the voice recording to open their closed eyes. Katia is using these objects stolen from mass media (the crisp, prerecorded human voice and the sounds of commotion during war) in the concert ritual to recreate her traumatic flashback and address the inescapability of this trauma. A symptom of trauma is the flashback, which whirls around one’s head constantly, rarely disappearing completely and unpredictably making vivd returns.
Anthony Rasmussen addresses this “looping” aspect of traumatic experience in his essay “Acoustic Patriarchy.” The violence of acoso callejero (street harassment) is preceded by an anticipation based on one’s surroundings. Its presence as a recurring traumatic event makes it so that victims to “prehear” the sounds of harassment. Such anticipation is followed by perception, the actual experience of acute violence. The present-ness of this moment is blurred and traumatic events are lived, relived, and triggered by familiar sights, sounds, and settings. The Our ability to resist trauma begins to fail:
The reductive foce of acoso callejero acts upon victims in myriad ways… despite the specificity of sensing bodies, there is a point at which [points of resistance] collapse under the weight trauma. For psychiatric historian Ruth Leys… ‘the experience of trauma, fixed or frozen in time, refuses to be represented as past, but is perpetually re-experienced in a painful, dissociated, traumatic present.’”
april 7 meditation utilizes the concert ritual to channel, contain, and take advantage of this aspect of trauma. What was experienced as a moment of witnessing is re-experienced here. It may even bear resemblance to the everyday experiences of the audience. Whose lives are increasingly lived in the hyper-violent hyperreal.
The incorporation of the sounds of trauma is not an act of domestication, which encourages the audience to come to peace with the event. Quite the opposite: after the singing bowls have finished playing, Geha’s direction to “open the eyes” highlights the turn back to reality and the true brutality of the traumatic event, both as an acute source of trauma for those present and the genuine trauma inflicted upon the audience. Taking use of the biopolitics of normative concert etiquette to arrest the audience for an enduring length of time, april 7 meditation forces us to reckon with the entirety of a piece of media that would usually be seen for mere seconds. This disrupts the trivializing narrative imposed on the scene by its situation in short-form media and acknowledges its ability to traumatize.
“With one deep breath out. Scan your body for tension and as you find it, release it. You have plenty of time to think about the past, you have plenty of time to think about the future, but in this moment, just enjoy the space to be in the now. So first just bringing the attention to the breath. And noticing where you feel it,”
The spatial and temporal aspects of the work make potent cultural statements on their own. Understood together, Geha’s commentary about collective trauma becomes all the more provocative. Mhamad Safa’s essay “Reverberations and post-war trauma” attends to the ability of persistent reverberations to produce a perpetually violence space through bombardment’s literal reverberations in the city scape and in the minds and imaginations of the victims of war: …[the 2006 the 2006 Israel-Lebanon] war’s prolonged reverberations had drifted further into deeper neural circuits that had completely altered the victims’ cognition of sound and space… generating a vulnerable population on which power was influenced. For Geha, like the civilians targeted in the IDF’s 2006 strike described by Safa, trauma reverberates in the mind. In this case, the reverberations manifest in the constant looping back to the video of the burning corpse, its twitching, and the calamity of a different IDF strike’s aftermath. Geha’s spatial injunction, submerging the audience in the mind-space, forces us to live this loop alongside her, reckoning with our own similar lived experiences. “I could not get this image out of my head.” Now, we can’t get it out of the collective “head” in which we have been entombed.
With such a confrontational injunction, the audience understands themselves to be victims by way of mediated witnessing, by way of the composer’s and performers’ hands at being forced to watch the events unfold, and by way of the people who have perpetuated such violence. Messaien’s Quartet for the End of Time has made itself a reputation as being one of few modernist works accepted into mainstream bourgeois chamber music culture. This canonization is a result of the vaguely anti-authoritarian mythos surrounding the composition of the piece as well its satisfying of the need for today’s neoliberal subjects to convince themselves that the end of history (end of time) really has taken place. In tonight’s presentation, the end of history myth is shattered in the juxtaposition of the two works. No longer does the first world have the ability to ignore the history that it levies on the Other when this history is spectacularized and brought home. It takes experiencing the violence of the “Imperial Boomerang” to realize this fact.
“perhaps in the belly, the chest, or maybe the shoulders. And we’re going to be taking some deep breaths. In through the nose for four, holding it for four, and then breathing out the mouth for six. It’s that fire we’re trying to sustain within us. It could be anger that we’re trying to tame, or that fire of joy and passion, that we are trying to gain. Take note of not overindulging, but sustaining that energy.”
Official spectacles of violence and sacrifice are foundational to projects of nation building and attempts by the state to construct solidarities between them and the working class. Ruth Gilmore summarizes this succinctly in her writing on the mediatization of Rodney King and Anita Hill:
The ideology of nation demands sacrifice; the enactment of the warfare state demands human sacrifice. And further, both the forces and the relations of ideological production in the warfare state—in other words the crisis state—require an excess of accused, of enemies, especially if the state is successfully to exact austerity from an economy whose polity expects, as a right, indulgence (transcendent, TV-reified innocence), prosperity, excess.
The broadcasting and delocalization on a national scale through the channels of television make examples out of the chosen subjects of state violence. The sacrifice is ritualized: testimony and repetition of violent acts are brought into the living room. Standard seating arrangements and a fixed gaze towards an altar, accompanied by specific food ready-made for this ritual, allow one to fully immerse themselves in viewing the sacrificial offerings of King and Hill.
The sacrifice of april 7 meditation is different in that it is broadcast via different media, although it retains the on-the-ground expose-style perspective as the Rodney King case. However, it is taken out of the ritual environment of short form media – the bedroom, the screen gripped inches from the face – and inserted into a concert ritual. Through this migrated experience of trauma the audience is forced to give it pause, to meditate with it as Geha has been. “Should I really be calming down?” is the question Geha asks herself in the program note for the work, a question that is rendered impossible by when the pacifying trivialization of Mass Media is taken for granted. Through the transference of the source of trauma in the concert ritual we (audience and performers) are collectively performing the inescapability of trauma and forced to question the omnipresence of sacrificial violence put into the short form. “Should I really be calming down?” becomes “should we really be calming down?” or an even more implicating “should you be calming down?”
“Mentally write an ode…
An ode to the love, the faith, whether it is your lack of it, or abundance of it, it is still there.
I am safe, I am grounded, my heart is at peace.
And when you’re ready, in your own time, gently opening the eyes again.”
We are tempted to think that Geha will end the piece after this verse and that april 7 meditation is about using meditation to heal from trauma, which is simply represented in the acousmatic commotion and burning sounds we hear. Not quite – no satisfying return. When the meditation concludes and we are prompted to open our eyes we are confronted with the sustained video of the burning body that Geha could not escape.
april 7 meditation is not using the concert ritual to distract or escape, but to heal through active experience. Geha is answering an imperative set forth by Gloria Anzaldúa:
The Coyolxauhqui imperative is to heal and achieve integration… Coyolxauhqui is my symbol of the necessary powers of dismemberment and fragmentation, of seeing that self or the situations you’re embroiled in differently. It is also my symbol for reconstruction and reframing, one that allows for putting the pieces back together in a new way. The Coyolxauhqui imperative is an ongoing process of making and unmaking. There is never any resolution, just the process of healing.
This healing does not close esta “herida abierta” (this open wound), that meeting place in the borders between countries rich and poor – it teaches how to live with it and within it. It teaches us that the bleeding of this wound is a place unto itself, a place which, with the ubiquitous broadcasting of violence, might be between our ears. The world becomes the open wound.
Though Anzaldúa is discussing the borderlands between Mexico and the US, there is no reason not to apply her ideas to other zones of active border creation. The video comes from one such zone – the active occupation and silencing of Palestine. These fictive differences between humans and nations give way to a pluralistic state of identity that is the borderlands itself. This identity is marked by the violence of maintaining difference between the first and third world through the moments of their proximity.
Acknowledging this identity founded upon violence – one which, via the extension of violence into the quotidian, becomes increasingly common – peels back the essential reification of subjectivity enacted by the border. Without any essential identity, in a Derridian turn, the constructed différance between identities becomes the true meaning of identity itself. The reified relationships between peoples come to be seen as fictions written by neoliberal capitalism, the system which produced the categories for today’s subjects to fall into.
Esta herida abierta is on full display in front of us, existing not only in the very real violence of the video’s contents but also in the short form medium through which we receive it. Forced to reckon with the wound impressed into our head, we find a latent violence in our own identities and an emerging solidarity with the victims of this violence on screen.
“…and if you’re quiet enough, you might learn more about the spark.
How does it sit in your body?”
In Scorched Earth: Beyond the Digital Age to a Post-Capitalist World, Jonathan Crary makes a passing remark about the promising place music holds in culture today while discussing the otherwise bleak aspects of culture under the present stage of capitalism. He observes, quoting Felix Guattari, that:
Young people are prompted to find their own thoughts boring or worthless… Spontaneity vanishes amid incessant images of violence, joyless pornography, cruelty and mockery. Music, in spite of its global commodification, remains one of the ways they can contrive ‘a bare minimum of singularity.’
Geha capitalizes on this potential energy. april 7 meditation does not rely on the shock value of the pacifying culture described by Crary but channels trivialized quotidian violence to inspire consciousness in her audience. The concert ritual has been transformed into a site of social reckoning. Collective solidarities are formed around trauma that would be otherwise experienced in an atomized consumption environment.
According to Diana Taylor “[t]heatricality makes that scenario [of conquer] alive and compelling… scenarios exist as culturally specific imaginaries – sets of possibilities, ways of conceiving conflict, crisis, or resolution – activated with more or less theatricality.” Domination is constructed through performance and theatre, characters acting in scenarios. Geha takes this domination and transfers it to a new scenario. This new stage realizes the power of performance observed by Taylor and the potential of music observed by Crary.
Geha’s work and its performance directly addresses the prerogatives of two artists:
- Gloria Anzaldúa: “my job as an artist is to bear witness to what haunts us, to step back and attempt to see the pattern in these events (personal and societal), and how we can repair el daño (the damage) by using the imagination and its visions.”
- Toni Cade Bambara: “The task of the artist is determined always by the status and process and agenda of the community that it already serves… As a cultural worker who belongs to an oppressed people my job is to make revolution irresistible.”
The work and its performance necessitate a bearing witness as a means of repair and inspire fury and a call to action against the perpetrators of the violence within the work. Crucially, it addresses these prerogatives only in live performance where we are active participants in the witnessing act as audience members. This experience cannot be recorded.
We need to heal, we need to heed Valencia’s call for “new axes of resistance.” april 7 meditation “opens the door for us to rethink gore capitalism and, using feminist tools, to forge a new discourse and sustainable practices that will move us away from it.” Work like this is not revolution. However, the channeling of violence accomplished through the live performance of Geha’s work is one step forward in confronting the trauma of the bleak neoliberal quotidian.
