“We become not a melting pot but a beautiful mosaic. Different people, different beliefs, different yearnings, different hopes, different dreams.”
—Jimmy Carter
i.
All together now Democrats who are either already in or are running for office: Only one party hates America!
Hint: it’s not the party that fights for health care, making sure that the most obscenely wealthy pay a fraction of the taxes which they owe (taxes that will, you know, repair roads, build bridges, employ police and fire fighters, etc.); it’s not the party that believes in both science and the arts.
No need to assert or even imply that all Republican hate America (that’s what they do to Democrats); it’s enough to point out that the hardest core MAGA voters hate everything that America represents, both in theory and practice. Put another way, they don’t hate America so much as they love the America that they wish it was, which is something it never has been or will be: a pipe dream that’s equal parts Heritage Foundation and Fox News fed fantasy where there’s a strong middle class but hard-right leadership, no illegal (or legal!) immigration, but low prices and a reliable workforce that helped keep the less desirable jobs filled and allows for businesses ranging from your local pizza joint to your favorite online megastore (or grocery store, whose shelves don’t get filled by invisible robots), where everyone is free to worship according to what they believe in (or not), so long as it’s the right religion. Unfettered First Amendment rights, unless you don’t approve of which way the culture shifts, or you’re a billionaire who owns a media platform but can’t tolerate being criticized. And so on…
The actual America, the tumultuous, contradictory, aspirational mess that already exists has always been a work in progress, a wonderful, often bloody, occasionally awe-inspiring rough draft. A nation that on a fundamental level is self-aware that it’s an idea becoming a reality, and only then through being a set of united states. (That means slave-loving territories can’t throw a tantrum and walk away or else declare war when forbidden to perpetuate a grotesquely immoral system that nevertheless helped build the literal bricks, mortar, fields and freeways of this nation). It is, in short, a gorgeous melting pot—and that cliche not only still applies, it transcends; it’s pure art. America, as experiment and legacy is filled with ethnicities, accents, attitudes, and aspirations—one huge dream that can accommodate individuals who want to be doctors, or writers, or CEOs, or athletes, and everything in between.
We used to mostly agree on this.
Never forget: the nativist impulse, aside from being myopic and self-defeating, has always inspired lowest common denominator opportunism: self-proclaimed pilgrims have punched down (figuratively and literally) on the newest kids on the block, from our freed slaves to our brothers and sisters arriving from south of our border who all the while labor for the lowest conceivable wages, pay taxes, and ensure that our economy hums. They are the actual invisible hands that allow a free market to function—and this is one of the more gruesome ironies conservative forces have cynically manipulated for decades, thanks in large part to a mostly supine, incurious, click-bait hungry infotainment media landscape.
ii.
I remember first learning I wasn’t white my second year of college.
Well, not really white.
And by not really white, I mean that I first encountered other white people (all men, not coincidentally) who were from hometowns south of northern Virginia (definitely not coincidentally), who considered my heritage (descended from Irish and Italian immigrants) less than, and the faith I then identified with (Catholic) not only non-optimal, but suspect; things like the pope and Second Vatican not in line with their type of Jesus—one I neither recognized nor remembered reading about. A Jesus I came to understand, with increasing clarity in the decades ahead, that was a decidedly white, blue-eyed alpha male, his teachings more consistent seemingly with capitalism than Christianity as I understood it.
It was my first confrontation with a cultural cognitive dissonance that was, at once, profound and trivial. Until this point, I certainly had not considered (or been taught to consider) my own perspective superior; it was that the faith and patriotism I grew up with, even or especially from more conservative sources, stressed that E pluribus unum was sacrosanct, not only as a theory, but in practice. We were better because we perfected an imperfect democracy that recognized many cultures contributing to a single overarching identity. This meant we could take the best elements from the wide world and focus it into an inclusive global power, a philosophical notion in practice where it was not only conceivable, but achievable for even the lowest—with hard work, with a dream—to join ranks with the connected and secure. And cultured. This was the critical ambition shared by both recent immigrants and old-school Yankees: getting an education, learning history and art, maybe a foreign language, all of which were meant to augment one’s character, improve one’s chances of rising through the ranks, and not for nothing, make one a better human being.
Once upon a time, college was the proving ground where one could become more than the sum of purely intellectual parts; what you learned was crucial, but the outside-the-classroom education was also invaluable. One could figuratively join a centuries old tradition linking people sufficiently curious to push past the safe but ignorant spaces of tribes and exclusive clubs. And while all this was happening, there was the movement to include women and minorities: we weren’t progressive, but we were making progress. (This is why we did—and some of us still do—celebrate about the ‘60s, warts and all.) It was easy in someways to declare that if you don’t at least tolerate these ideas, you are backward, you’re closer to people who abet authoritarianism (if not fascism, back in a seemingly distant era where Nazis were unambiguously evil; the bad guys we secured civilization from, in movies like Raiders of the Lost Ark and in real life).
How quaint. How naïve. And I think this is what both MAGA and the ultra-woke/progressive movements miss: America was at once better and worse than it is today, and in some senses, always has been. Indeed, this wonderful, curious tension is what enables a democracy to endure. By understanding that those who went before us worked harder, under more extreme circumstances, and helped enable our more accessible pathways to prosperity was not inconsistent with a view that all of us are – that America itself is – a work in progress. We can always do better, invite more people to the table, create better policies, invent more effective medicine, strive toward an environment where we could keep dreaming while feeling safer and more indispensable while we were awake.
iii.
I’m not certain if it has anything to do with what you study in college, or the type of person you already are (of course the two are not mutually exclusive) but speaking for myself, I suspect that if you are a certain age and not already convinced that God is White and the GOP is Right (and anyone under the age of twenty-one is already a lost cause, intellectually and morally), reading a book like The Road To Wigan Pier changes you. Reading a book like The Junglechanges you. Books like Madame Bovarychange you. Books like The Second Sexchange you. Books like Notes from Undergroundchange you. Books like Invisible Manchange you. Then you might start reading poetry and come to appreciate what William Carlos Williams meant when he wrote “It is difficult to get the news from poems, yet men die miserably every day for lack of what is found there.” These works alter your perception of the big picture: cause and effect, agency vs. incapacity and history vs. ideology.
Put another way, even if you are open-minded and receptive to various sources of information, if your studies focus on economics, business or political science you are already being inculcated into an established way of thinking. Liberal arts education, if it has anything going for it (and it has plenty), reinforces and insists upon what Milan Kundera called a “furious nonidentification.” This does not mean to imply that all, or most, or even some of the students who embrace (or abscond from) the ivory tower remain inquisitive and objective. It does mean that reading works from different cultures and different times inevitably denotes truths and facts (even if couched in fictional narratives) that are outside of time and agenda.
It is, therefore, easier to make connections between Irish immigrants who worked the coal mines in Pennsylvania and Lithuanian immigrants who worked in the meatpacking plants in Chicago (Jurgis Rudkus, anyone?) and Mexican immigrants—especially the illegal ones—who labor in sweltering kitchens and frigid fields all across our country. It is impossible not to put human faces and real feelings alongside this suffering and start understanding how exploitation works. All of a sudden, it’s harder to espouse the impartial axioms of the Free Market and the immutable forces of commerce or the notion that (in America anyway) everyone starts out at the same place and that those who work hard enough and say their prayers and drink their milk will attain vast fortunes without the aid of breaking laws, stepping on innocent faces and engaging in the oppressive pas de deux with Power (and the puny but influential people who possess it). Then, presumably, it goes from being merely disconcerting to outrageous that the weasels of Wall Street are back in business with billion-dollar bonuses (thanks taxpayers!) and unionized public school teacher pensions are being blamed for America’s current deficits.
I don’t have any illusions that if some of these folks had actually read Kafka or Orwell they’d think differently, or if they watched movies (especially ones with sub-titles) the shock of recognition would occur—or could occur, which is both the potential and promise of art. But it’s dejecting to watch otherwise intelligent people advocate for censorship, the active demonization of certain groups, and rallying around a cult of might makes right, and never recognize anything that gives them pause. And I think in part this is because history repeats itself (duh) but more that the very people who did make America great(er) have afforded us the luxury of ignorance, of believing we don’t have to be wary and cognizant, we don’t have to remember the lessons of the past, that we can undo certain guardrails and polices that took decades to crate without repercussions (that anyone suffers should be unbearable, but that it requires certain folks to feel pain in order to understand cause and effect is at once infuriating and embarrassing).
But this is also how reactionary forces have hijacked narrative: being a red-blooded American means not having to consider these things; we’re always-already better by virtue of being American. In other words, certain people are genuinely offended if you use the N word (Nazi) because to their minds it’s literally inconceivable that “don’t let it happen here” could happen here; that comparisons can (and must) be made between how acquiescence is indeed the slippery slope that leads to atrocity, that putting “illegals” in cages is incompatible with (take your pick): American history, or Christian faith.
I’m fond of asking: how do we battle bad narrative?
Offer better narratives.
And we must do this, but we can’t rely on our artists and PR experts to save us; we all are capable of—and responsible for—sharing the good narratives from the good old days (be they Orwell or Indiana Jones or the New Testament) to remind people who we’ve been, who we became, who we used to strive to become. It’s a work in progress because we’re all works in progress.
