
Yolŋu women trek for kilometres atop the network of buttress roots anchoring the mangrove forest in the sweet black mud. There is a rhythm to the mud which a buried mud crab disturbs. Their holes, which are often wedged into hidden sections beneath the trees, are visible only to the trained eye. Then begins the task of extracting the crab with massive vice like pincers, from their deep dark wet hole—usually with bare hands!
— Will Stubbs, Gathul- gärri / Into the Mangroves (2022)
Collaborations between Indigenous artists and curators of European de-scent have explored the decolonizing possibilities of amphibious landscapes. One such exhibition was at Cross Art Projects in Sydney (December 2022), curated by Jo Holder and Will Stubbs, titled RISE 3: Mangrove Thinking. This work showed how the intertidal ecosystems that support mangroves have historically been the objects of colonial distrust and aggression, while also celebrating “mangrove thinking” as anticolonial, restorative, and resilient. I’ve learned a lot from the work, which teaches non-Indigenous Australians that mangrove landscapes thrive on amphibious inwardness. Mangroves defy colonial models of how inwardness ought to work and ecosystems ought to look, and for this very reason mangroves were targeted for colonial misuse and at-tempted erasure. But the resonant phrase “mangrove thinking” challenges the assumption that landscapes are passive, unconscious, or without autonomous agency, and so it challenges the colonial belief that landscapes would be amenable to colonial control without pushing back. Instead, mangrove thinking takes as given that places think, and refutes the idea that interiors—both of people and places—can be treated extractively without making their own counternarratives.
Most of the art in Mangrove Thinking was made in Yirrkala, an Aboriginal community north of Darwin, in East Arnhem (Northern Territory). Holder and Stubbs match this with work by Sydney artists from around the La Perouse area, once home to the expansive mangroves of Cook’s River and now the site of Sydney’s international airport. The central concept of the exhibition is that art made with, by, and among mangroves always belongs to them, and that mangrove art helps make continuity between creative practice and the eco-logic of these amphibious plants. The work also reflects the belief that human imagination and representation is continuous with that of other living beings—trees, marine organisms. While the exhibition presents the First Nations artists’ account of mangroves as anticolonial and non-European, it also extends an invitation to non-Indigenous viewers to rethink their beliefs about amphibious landscapes.
“Sydney’s ambiguous anti-mangrove history,” as curator Jo Holder calls it, arose because mangroves were misinterpreted as waste or purposeless “swamps,” places where water stagnated and land became uselessly water-logged. Colonization itself made mangroves fragile. At the same time, how-ever, colonists and their descendants misinterpreted mangroves as infinitely resilient, stubbornly resistant to removal or “reclamation” as useful land, treating trees like unwanted people, even as they refused the idea that human consciousness was continuous with environment. Mangroves in areas of colonial development were (and still are) dumping grounds for urban trash, as if being “punished” for having ugly foliage and obstructing river mouths and water-fronts. Will Stubbs, coordinator of the Yirrkala Arts Center, writes about how in urban coastal areas “[gathul/mangroves] are so misused that you can see through the straggle of trees to the built landscape beyond. Where they are thick enough, they are used as rubbish dumps with broken glass and tyres growing in the mud.” Rubbish in mangroves reflects the perverse belief that they are indestructible, obstinately permanent, even as their liminal, fluctuating nature is what makes them offensive in the first place. Mangroves were thus turned into the landscapes they were mistaken for: hard-to-dislodge waste grounds; foreshores gone wrong.
Mangrove Thinking transforms these assumptions about mangroves by putting the harvesting and eating of food at the center of what amphibious ecosystems—intertidal zones—mean for First Nations cultures. Living in and with mangroves and making art with them restore metabolic continuities be-tween the inner lives of place and humans and more-than-human lives. Far from obstructing the growing and harvesting of food, as early colonists imagined, mangroves sustain it. Their dense, opaque interior landscapes protect fish, mollusks, and crabs. “Harvesting the fruits of the mangrove is the particular obsession of Yolŋu [Northeast Arnhem] women. Their knowledge of what lies within and under the trees and the mud is incredible. For, as beautiful as what can be seen is, there is hidden treasure everywhere—for those who can crack the code.” Those who “crack the code” are the women who know how to enter the interior world of mangroves wisely; walk on tree rootsand harvest mussels, crabs, and other shellfish; and light fires with mangrove wood in a way that generates heat powerful enough to open the shells for eating. Mangroves are fragile only in the sense that they are extraordinarily sensitive, responsive environments, alert to change. The inner lives of mangroves are permeable, entered by water and air—by warmth from sunlight that is exchanged for coolness from shade and water, light becoming dimness as you move further in. Mangroves absorb, filter, nurture, nourish, and give out filtered water, air, food, and nutrient-dense feces. The bark painter Muluymuluy Wirrpanda, an elder of the Dhudi-Djapu clan of the Dhuwa moiety of East Arnhem, emphasizes the resilience and power that imagination acquires when it belongs to amphibious places. Stubbs writes, following Muluymuluy’s thinking: “it should be understood that these paintings are not still lifes. They are an ode to the activity of being within this magic world.”
At the heart of Mangrove Thinking is a series of Muluymuluy’s ochres on bark. These depict mangrove snorkels and trees and living above the waterline, mirrored by an extensive subaquatic root system that provides homes for oysters and other mollusks. Muluymuluy’s images suggest continual flows and continuities between air and water, leaves and roots, trees and animals. Drawn in sharply contrasting ochre lines, the images project resilience and presence: They allow the viewer to see mangroves with a level of detail that is not apparent to observers who pass by mangroves without entering them and participating in the life they contain. Accompanying Muluymuluy’s barks are two works by her sister Ms. Wirrpanda, an acclaimed Yirrkala artist who died in 2021. Ms. Wirrpanda depicts gathul (mangrove) patterning in ochre on memorial poles, called larrakitj. Larrakitj are hollowed lengths of stringybark gum that hold enormous cultural value because they traditionally were made to store the ground bones of deceased ancestors in order that their spirits remain in community with the living.
The Yolnu work sits alongside a group of playfully melancholy pieces by La Perouse (Sydney) artists Lola Ryan and Rose Timbery. Ryan and Timbery make small shellwork objects, reflecting on interconnections between Indigenous and European ways of seeing during early colonial contact. The artistic tradition of shellwork was passed through a lineage of female artists from the La Perouse area around Gwea/Botany Bay, following in the footsteps of their matriarch “Queen” Emma Timbery. During the nineteenth century, in the aftermath of white invasion, Emma Timbery gathered shells from the beaches around where Captain Cook had first landed. She arranged the shells to deco-rate mementos such as heart-shaped boxes and baby booties. The objects are European tokens used to memorialize important events, but Timbery’s shell-work reclaimed them in order to recover Indigenous representational practice. First Nations shellwork expresses both grief and memory, suggesting that the shells themselves hold the feelings of those who have gathered them, then and now.
For First Nations people in early colonial New South Wales, shells were a powerful and deeply threatened resource. They were used in trade and ex-change between people of the Eora nation and the colonizers: as currency. But shells were also used for colonial building projects. Aboriginal shell middens, important forms that marked places of gathering and ceremony for coastal societies, were burned by the British to make lime mortar. I discuss oyster shells and lime burning in sections III and V, but I note here that the seemingly simple craft of shellwork holds a complicated set of narratives that interweave grief, memory, and resilience and depict these experiences as being shared between First Nations people and early white colonial settlers. These interconnected states of being are linked by the trope of “mangrove thinking,” which itself celebrates the amphibious as a mode of experience in which both humans and ecosystems participate.
Mangrove thinking understands interiority as both metabolic and imaginative, intimate and collective. It celebrates amphibious borderlines as creative and life-intense sites—not frontiers or containers needing to be penetrated and regulated. Mangroves are a precious place of rich interiority in which hidden organisms can be found by reading the terrain with skill and knowledge: “feeling with feet or combing with hands, knife blades or rakes [mussels] are sometimes spotted as cryptic lips just poking free of the mud or as a hole or crack in the surface of the mud indicating a subsidence below where [dhän’pala/mud mussel] has moved.” Mangroves are landscapes that make feasts, which is another way of saying they’re places that make subjectivity and community through embodied, metabolic processes that move continuously between human, animal, and plant consciousness.
Excerpted from The Barbarous Feast: Eating and Writing in the Eighteenth-Century World Copyright © 2026 by Sophie Gee. Available from Princeton University Press.
