pittsburgh review of books logo

The Lies We Learned to Love

Part One: When We Started Rooting for the Villains

i.

Emerging from a mysterious bout of food poisoning, I found myself, in between urgent trips to the loo and the sluggish agonies of full-body fevers, contemplating how such a condition is an ideal metaphor for a lot of the anti-democratic turds polluting the current state of our sociopolitical reality.

It occurs to me, as it often does, that everything is narrative. Obviously. But all narratives are ultimately driven by power. Or money (or getting laid). Really, so much human activity, especially the violent kind, originates from a desire to attain or accrue more power, to attain or accrue more money, get laid, or get back at all the women who rejected you. And connecting all these threads is the universal but also peculiarly American brand of toxic masculinity that has metastasized in places of power in our contemporary political, business, and athletic arenas.

Which brings me to what’s been happening in America pretty much forever, but especially since 2015 and every single day since late 2024. And that brings me to Elon Musk, which brings me to Mark Zuckerberg, which brings me to Donald Trump, which brings me to Gordon Gekko, which brings me to Ronald Reagan, which brings me to Teddy Roosevelt, which brings me to Upton Sinclair, which brings me to Abraham Lincoln, which brings me…you get the picture.

First, food poisoning.

What do I mean about narrative? Because so many of my generation (and before and after, of course), if they think about regulation at all, envision government inefficiency. This is a masterstroke of narrative: we’ve been inculcated, with Pavlovian precision, to associate “Big Government” with intrusive entities, those boring and prissy agents who stymie innovation, forming a sort of bureaucratic blockade of our geniuses always five steps ahead and fully outside the one-dimensional boxes all of us boring normal folk happily exist inside.

When I think of regulation, first and foremost I consider Upton Sinclair (in general) and The Jungle (in particular). It was, of course, this book that exposed the unsavory conditions at meatpacking plants and helped prompt Teddy Roosevelt and Congress to enact landmark food-safety and meat-inspection laws in 1906. These reforms were part of a longer movement toward federal oversight, but Sinclair accomplished something indispensable: he made the consequences of inadequate regulation impossible for ordinary Americans to ignore.

And here’s the thing: this wasn’t simply an attempt to organize the chaotic machinery of commerce; this was a corrective against immoral cretins who would knowingly, routinely pay less, use spoiled meat, endorse child labor, and oversee demonstrably unsafe working conditions, all to make the tiniest bit more profit. Because that’s good business.

This is narrative.

It’s beyond appalling that we are ceaselessly listening to brazen politicians whining about regulation and how “too much” of it is killing job creation; now we have them insisting that “DEI” and “woke” are responsible for anything that goes wrong.

If only.

The USA has been on one extended deregulation bender since the Reagan era, and the results have been disastrous for working people, public protections, and our ability to imagine government as anything other than an obstacle.

I’ve had too many discussions to count hearing right-wingers (or self-declared libertarians) proclaim that corporations are not individuals and, moreover, no corporation will knowingly behave immorally because it’s bad business. Of course, the contrary is often the case: it is good business to deregulate, cut out the middlemen, enfeeble mechanisms of oversight, eliminate as many positions as possible, spend as little on optimal (and safe) working conditions as you can get away with, and splash the obscene profits on marketing and out-of-court settlements. The despicable Jeff Bezos has essentially turned this into 21st-century Gospel.

“It’s bad business,” these enablers will insist. “No company wants to get caught poisoning food, or water, or making dangerous products because then people won’t support them.”

Really?

How’s that working out for every fast-food franchise, oil conglomerate, and earth-raping manufacturing behemoth? Or any juggernaut that can pay to make the bad press go away (or, increasingly, just buy the largest newspapers and print all the news that fits its agenda)?

And yet it’s too easy, and too late, to blame only the CEOs and businesses. At this point, this is on us, and it’s a collective, late-stage-empire kind of fail. We’ve seen by now that we should expect the worst from institutions rewarded for placing profit above virtually every other consideration. At a certain point, if someone lies to you enough times, it becomes your responsibility to stop believing them, however painful it may be to acknowledge reality—or the “alternate facts.”

The mess we’re in is only conceivable because, as a nation, we don’t demand regulation and benefits and the so-called “entitlements” (that we pay to have provided to us at a later time, making the word “entitlement” about as sensical as Bush’s Orwellian “Clear Skies” initiative) that we end up with arsenic in our food.

We are still letting ourselves be told not to believe our lying eyes: decades of trickle-down economics have been sold as a prescription for broadly shared prosperity even as the gains from economic growth have flowed disproportionately upward, leaving working Americans struggling with stagnant purchasing power, insecurity, and diminished public services.

And even after financial crises exposed the dangers of the alternate reality of Free Market Utopia, there are people protesting that we have too much government in our lives. If you watch Fox News or are congenitally disinclined to understand cause and effect, we can see how, against all possibility, this is still happening.

ii.

The reason this is crucial is because it’s been the Republican Superpower since at least 1980.

Whatever the actual record of Republican governance—and whatever the contradictions between the party’s rhetoric about fiscal restraint and its willingness to embrace deficits, tax cuts, and expensive political priorities—the GOP has mastered the art of messaging.

Here’s how it works. Once upon a time Ronald Reagan drew a conservative line in the sand, assailing the presumption of government as a constructive agent, not by nitpicking but by taking aim at its raison d’être. With a country still reeling from the apathy and cynicism of the post-Nixon nadir, he preempted that anger and uttered the immortal words:

“Government is not the solution to our problem; government is the problem.”

And with that, Republicans assumed control of a powerful new storyline. It was simple as it was shameless; it was the most facile strategy fathomable, and the GOP finally had a patron saint to render it sacrosanct.

The Reagan Revolution built its momentum on a shameful vilification of America’s poor and lionized (some would say fetishized) the wealthiest percentile, transforming them into folk heroes. Reaganomics helped legitimize a political economy in which the richest Americans could claim ever-smaller tax burdens while the working class was told that prosperity would eventually trickle down.

Meanwhile, young pillagers in training perfected the business acumen of extracting profit from struggling companies into a repugnant performance art. This reached its apotheosis when truth Trumped reality (in every sense of the word) and we ended up electing an actual Gordon Gekko, sans charisma and liquidity.

But here’s the thing about Gekko as metaphor for the economy-crashers: he was supposed to be the villain. Wall Street was written as an over-the-top, even ham-fisted cautionary tale, but Michael Douglas played his role to such greasy perfection that an unhealthy number of Gen X bros and wannabes apparently watched that movie and said, “Yes, more of that, please.”

And Gekko was hardly the only lesson my generation absorbed. Consider an example as innocuous as Ghostbusters. Not for nothing was the, allegedly, dickless Walter Peck (!) a government hack, but from the dreaded EPA, no less!

There we were, fully ensconced in the Reagan Fever Dream, where it was open season on those annoying and nerdy regulators who worried about trivial laws that pertained to public health; get out of the way, man, we’re busting ghosts!

And the people lining the streets, cheering on these mavericks, can today be seen retweeting Elon Musk, in the sad hope that he’ll see it and offer a digital high five. That there’s actually the possibility, however remote, that Elon Musk will see it and offer a digital high five manages to be even more depressing.

Narrative.

iii.

Speaking of Gen X and having come of age in the ’80s, it was at once surprising and appalling to see how strongly many members of this demographic supported Trump in 2024.

The kids are alright, perhaps, but what the holy hell is happening with the Breakfast Club? It seems improbable, if not outright impossible, that the generation that defined cynicism and can still recall a time before all-things-digital can’t see through all-things MAGA.

Until we consider narrative.

It seems safe to surmise that, for Gen Xers, so many of us thought being a cop meant Miami Vice, being a lawyer meant L.A. Law, and if you really had the hots for a girl, you just stalked her until she realized the error of her ways, à la mid-’80s John Hughes films. Or, to bring it all full circle, you just pull a Musk/Zuck and build the perfect woman, à la Weird Science. Small wonder the playing field is littered with disenchanted, demoralized, much-divorced dudes and pitiful incels.

We were the generation that supposedly knew better. We recognized hypocrisy, mocked authority, and cultivated skepticism as an identity. But perhaps the trouble with making cynicism your defining worldview is that it becomes remarkably easy to mistake contempt for wisdom, cruelty for authenticity, and self-interest for rebellion.

A generation raised on the mythology of the individualistic outsider might have been unusually susceptible to men who present themselves as disruptors, even when what they’re disrupting is the possibility of collective progress.

Narrative.

Revisiting The Social Network (while ill, no less) is such a cringey hate-watch, it obliges any fiction writer to think, “Yes, good stuff, but over the top.” And then you see Zuck write a $25 million check for Trump’s inauguration, his ridiculous Caesar perm, that embarrassing necklace, and think, “Holy shit, it’s even worse than the movie; he’s so banal and empty of original thought he’s somehow beyond satire.”

Suffice it to say, Aaron Sorkin’s forthcoming The Social Reckoning is certain to be equal parts illuminating, infuriating, and nauseating.

Which of course brings us to Trump and, to a lesser extent, back to Musk.

That these are men whose public personas so often resemble developmentally arrested adolescents—whose entire existences seem devoted to accumulating the most toys, preferably at others’ expense, because the zero-sum game is now the First Commandment of any patriotic True Believer—is bad enough.

That we’ve elevated them into cultural authorities is something else altogether. And it will never not be ironic or depressing that Gordon Gekko ended up becoming a patron saint who codified all the wrong lessons from the ’80s.

iv.

Which, as always and as ever, brings us back to story, narrative, and messaging.

And how the Democrats can never get out of their own way to address why and how they’re so abysmal on practically all levels at it. Conversely, their opposition, whose words and deeds are so often manifestly, demonstrably horrific, manages to stay on point and long ago mastered the seemingly minor but imperative task of finding short, punchy, provocative talking points they recite as easily as they breathe.

What the Democrats need, and have long needed, is a small menu of one-word terms to help define the opposition, to paint the proverbial picture that, somehow, ten million words and recorded history from the last several decades can’t articulate.

For my money, “weird” was working, and indeed, was the first thing in ages to visibly rattle the right people. Look how everyone from Trump to JD Vance to Musk and his always-online army of dorks reacted, unable to laugh it off, congenitally incapable of denying it hit home, identifying and homing in on their soft spot, thinly concealed beneath their very soft, white, pudgy flesh.

It will be a mystery, for a long time, why the Dems, having finally found the ideal, succinct messaging and the absolutely perfect messenger in Tim Walz (indeed, wasn’t that the single reason he was chosen for the gig?), essentially muzzled him and let this rare opportunity go to waste. Unless it’s entirely explicable, unless the easy, depressing answer is of course the Dems did this because that’s what Dems do.

Any introductory class in marketing or communications (or English literature, for that matter) will emphasize the importance of narrative; the necessity of telling the story you want to tell. Hell, a cursory review of The West Wing would do the trick for any recalcitrant or oblivious communications directors.

But the larger failure isn’t simply that Democrats are bad at inventing slogans, it’s that they continue allowing their opponents to define the terms of the argument. If government is inherently the problem, then every government failure confirms the story, while every government success becomes something to explain away or ignore. If wealth is evidence of virtue, then the billionaire must know something the rest of us don’t. And if the self-interested bully is really a brave outsider, then accountability becomes persecution and every act of cruelty can be repackaged as courage.

This is what happens when narrative overwhelms reality.

What I’d like to say to all the folks who are either passively accepting this or, worse, abetting it or cheering it on, especially my Gen X brethren and sistren: Did you ever imagine you grew up watching James Bond and your life has been reduced to rooting for the silliest and most insidious villains from those movies? Worse still, with men like Musk and Zuck, it’s like identifying with—and advocating for—the caricature of those caricatures; not being content with Blofeld but fully on board with Dr. Evil?

This, in short, is how America gets more ridiculous with each generation. And here’s the problem with spending decades rooting for the villains: eventually, they get to decide how the story ends.

To be continued.

About the Author

Sean Murphy has been publishing fiction, poetry, reviews (of music, movie, book, food), and essays on the technology industry for over twenty years. He has appeared on NPR’s “All Things Considered” and been quoted in USA Today, The New York Times, The Huffington Post, and AdAge. A long-time columnist for PopMatters, his work has also appeared in Salon, The Village Voice, Washington City Paper, The Good Men Project, Memoir Magazine, and others. (Check out a sample of his portfolio here.) His chapbooks The Blackened Blues (Finishing Line Press) and Rhapsodies in Blue (Kelsay Books) were published in 2021 and 2023. His third poetry collection, Kinds of Blue and This Kind of Man, his first collection of short fiction, published in 2024. His novel Not To Mention a Nice Life was published in 2015, followed by his first two collections of non-fiction, Murphy’s Law, Vol One and Vol. Two. He has been nominated four times for the Pushcart Prize, twice for Best of Net, and his book Please Talk about Me When I’m Gone was the winner of Memoir Magazine’s 2022 Memoir Prize. He served as writer-in-residence of the Noepe Center at Martha’s Vineyard, and is Founding Director of 1455, a non-profit that celebrates storytelling.

Get the latest delivered to your inbox!

More Like This

Back to top ↑