Right now, in bars and living rooms across three countries, people are arguing about formations they couldn’t have explained a month ago. The largest World Cup ever held, with 48 teams and host cities stretching from Vancouver to Mexico City to Philadelphia, has done in a few weeks what soccer in America usually takes years to do: made the sport briefly impossible to avoid.
This happens every four years, and it is, in its way, wonderful. People who barely follow soccer suddenly know Kylian Mbappé’s name and can spell it. Jerseys appear in shop windows and offices. Kickoff times reorganize schedules. Casual viewers become sudden devotees.
The World Cup offers soccer at its grandest: national teams assembled from rival club systems, players carrying the hopes of entire countries, moments of athletic precision capable of stopping whole afternoons. Even people who do not normally watch sports can feel themselves pulled in.
But the tournament also teaches Americans an incomplete, even flawed, lesson about soccer.
Years ago, while writing Football: An Object Lesson, I began thinking about what I came to regard as the sport’s “two games.” There is the professional game: high-tech stadiums, television rights, immaculate grass and impossible levels of skill. And then there is the version most people actually play — pickup soccer in parks, schoolyards, church fields, parking lots and whatever patches of grass happen to be available.
The World Cup brilliantly displays one game.
It almost completely obscures the other.
This matters because, for most people around the world, soccer survives not through spectacle but through repetition: recurring matches among uneven players, borrowed space and loose obligations. Pickup soccer is not simply a lesser version of elite soccer. In many ways, it is the reason the professional version exists at all.
Pickup asks surprisingly little of its participants. A decent ball helps, though even that can be negotiated. Goals are improvised with backpacks or shirts dropped onto grass. Latecomers rotate in. The game ends when someone proposes “next goal wins,” which rarely means the game is actually over.
Anyone who wants to play is usually allowed to play. Rarely are teams formally chosen; they emerge. The play shifts according to who is there. Better players often dominate possession. Tempers flare and arguments happen. Some players become frustrated and stop showing up. Pickup soccer is not utopia.
Yet one of its virtues is that no authority resolves these tensions. No coach or referee settles disputes. Players collectively decide what fairness looks like because the alternative is ending the game altogether.
For more than 15 years, I have played pickup soccer with a mixed group in New Orleans ranging from preteens to retirees. The game predates me, beginning sometime in the late 1980s. Some players are deeply skilled; others are simply willing. There are students, doctors, plumbers, immigrants, teachers, baristas and actors (Woody Harrelson played a few times years ago while shooting True Detective). The game skews heavily male, though women and girls have been regulars as well. A former NASL pro, now 70 years old, doesn’t miss a match. New arrivals are always welcome. People come and go according to work schedules, injuries, and weather.
New Orleans may be unusually hospitable to this kind of arrangement — a city where people still linger in public and schedules remain slightly more permeable than elsewhere. But over the last decade, I have played pickup in other American cities and in Europe, and the culture remains remarkably recognizable: the same negotiations, the same mix of ability, the same quiet expectation that if you show up, you get to take part.
That expectation feels increasingly rare.
Pickup soccer asks remarkably little of people beyond presence. No registration fee or travel itinerary. No algorithm deciding who belongs. Much of how Americans gather now comes highly scheduled, optimized, and priced. Even leisure carries the faint pressure of performance.
This is one reason the sport has often developed differently in the United States than elsewhere. Globally, soccer became the world’s game partly because of its democratic accessibility: all that was required was a ball, a handful of people and enough room to move.
American youth sports work in the opposite direction. Pay-to-play leagues, private coaching and travel teams have made organized soccer expensive and rigid. Informal play has declined. Studies of youth sports regularly show children leaving organized play around early adolescence, often because it stops being fun.
During the pandemic, our pickup group briefly adopted a variation called “three touch,” in which no player could touch the ball more than three times before passing or shooting. The adjustment began as practical improvisation to limit prolonged contact, but it changed the game in ways that surprised us.
Players who usually held the ball too long discovered they could no longer play in their preferred style. Dominant players had to adapt. The game demanded not simply passing but movement: if your teammate only had limited touches, you had to anticipate where they would need you and move into space accordingly.
We became less attached to individual moments of brilliance and more invested in collective buildup. Technique improved because players had to adjust. We connected more, tactically as well as emotionally, and the game itself became better.
Years later, I still think of those matches often. In Football, I called the chapter on this experiment “The Life-Changing Magic of Three Touch,” only partly joking. Constraint, unexpectedly, made the game feel more generous.
I saw another version of this while recently teaching a course on soccer and culture with my colleague Nathan Henne at Loyola University New Orleans. Rather than discussing nationalism, labor, globalization or analytics one afternoon, we divided the class between those who would play pickup soccer and those who would watch and take notes.
The assignment was simple: closely read the match.
The game quickly became more revealing than we expected.
One student obsessively kept score long after others had quietly stopped counting. Some players monopolized possession while others barely touched the ball. One player became desperate to score and only worsened their chances by refusing to pass.
Nathan, who hasn’t played since a skiing injury cost him a kneecap, stood at the sideline. Pickup soccer had shifted from participation to spectatorship for him, though not disengagement.
“Passing is legal!” he shouted. “Come on, that’s your shot!”
His remarks landed somewhere between heckling and encouragement.
At one point, a student nutmegged me — slipping the ball through my legs — entirely by accident. I stopped briefly to acknowledge it anyway. Pickup soccer contains small rituals of recognition.
Afterward, students noticed how quickly informal hierarchies emerged. More confident players became captains. Generous players adjusted their games to include weaker ones. Without quite realizing it, the class had begun reading soccer not only as sport but as social life: frustration, generosity, improvisation, cooperation, and disagreement unfolding in real time without mediation.
I’ve come to think you can’t really understand the first game without knowing the second one exists. The spectacle needs the substrate. The sport is not just Mbappé. The sport is the fact that a group of people of different backgrounds and abilities, people who have nowhere better to be, are working something out together, as they have been for more than a century.
The World Cup gets one month. The game I love never ends.
